Fans of Rozalia Russian (left) and Georgia Fowler can pay for early access to their wardrobes via Pre-Loved Closet.
Toilet paper, television, magazines, supermarket delivery, and even undies. There are few everyday essentials that haven’t been touched by the subscription wand in the past few years.
When it comes to fashion, membership-based services are also increasing. Subscriptions to underwear (Peggy and Finn, Hello Peachie, Knobby) and clothing (Threadicated, Stitch Fix) have been around for a while, but a new class of membership sells access – to curated second-hand wardrobes, or big discounts on new gear. Other examples, such as My Virtual Stylist, offer a subscription-based personal shopping service. Brands have also been getting in on the act, with On Running offering a model for sustainable shopping where subscribers pay $30 a month to return their worn-out shoes for a new pair.
One emerging player is The Pre-Loved Closet, which sells the wardrobes of influencers such as Rozalia Russian and model Georgia Fowler. Founder Lisa Anderson, 30, says competition is fierce for the one-off garments, in particular from labels such as Zimmermann, so giving shoppers early access was a key driver for her decision to introduce memberships.
When Anderson was calculating how much to charge members, she studied “the Netflix model” and consulted e-commerce experts before settling on $7 a month – “less than two cups of coffee”, she says. Members also get discounts on shipping and don’t pay a 5 per cent buyers’ premium, which can often be more than the discounted $70 annual membership.
Gary Mortimer, a professor of marketing at Queensland University of Technology, says the cost of memberships, regardless of the field, needs to create a “perception of value”: too low, and the service may not feel sufficiently premium; too high, and consumers may worry they won’t get bang for buck.
In 2021, Julie Stevanja co-founded Her Black Book, an app that offers shoppers discounts and cash-backs from brands including Selfridges and Go-To skincare. For $25 a year, members get access to bigger discounts and special offers, including from brands that never go on sale, such as Gucci. The business has also expanded into homewares, wellness and beauty, and has launched a podcast.
Stevanja, who founded athleisure e-tailer Stylerunner (it was sold after going into voluntary administration in 2019), says about 50 per cent of the estimated 1000 offers on Her Black Book are exclusive to the app, and about 10 to 20 per cent are reserved for members. “We want a consumer to justify upgrading [to a paid] membership on the back of their first discount,” she says.
But subscriptions such as these aren’t only about saving money; there are myriad intangible factors, such as exclusivity, says behavioural specialist Bri Williams. “There’s an element of identity too,” she says. “It’s about being an ‘insider’.”
But how big are these clubs? And aren’t we all suffering from a bit of “subscription fatigue”?
While neither company would disclose raw member numbers, Stevanja says Her Black Book’s subscribers are growing 160 per cent every quarter. As for who is signing up, Her Black Book’s members are 80 per cent millennials or Gen Z, and 96 per cent identify as women. Anderson, meanwhile, says her members are growing by about 20 per cent each month.
Consumer psychologist and professor of marketing at Macquarie Business School, Jana Bowden, says subscriptions are likely to keep growing in popularity as people return to their time-poor, post-COVID lives. “There’s so much content, there’s so much information, it’s become quite overwhelming for consumers to find deals,” she says. “It’s exciting and a bit of a dopamine hit to find these seemingly exclusive offers delivered and curated just for you.”
And when all else fails, fashion businesses can always rely on FOMO (fear of missing out) to drive membership, says Gary Mortimer. “Teasing an offer creates anticipation and surprise ... and the fear that someone else will get access, and they might miss out.”
Order a style parcel today, one of our Threadicated stylists would love to help you create your dream capsule wardrobe. They'll style and send you five pieces to suit your lifestyle, shape and budget.